West Region Round of 32 Matchup Preview: 1 The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild vs. 8 Disco Elysium: The Final Cut

The Highest-Scored Game of the Era Against the Most Unconventional Game in the Tournament

Breath of the Wild beat Hi-Fi Rush in the Round of 64 by a score of 2-1, and the overall 1 seed advanced to the Round of 32 with a margin that felt appropriate for the round but not comfortable for a game of its stature. Nobody in this bracket is coasting. Nobody has the kind of lead that allows for anything less than full engagement from their community at every stage.

The game itself is the standard against which everything in this tournament is measured. A 97 on Metacritic. 141 critic reviews, the most of any game in the VGM era. Every major Game of the Year award in 2017. 33 million copies sold. The highest score of any game in the nine-year eligibility window. It came out on March 3, 2017, as a launch title for the Nintendo Switch, and it made a choice that many franchise games are too conservative to make. It threw away the established Zelda structure almost entirely. No dungeons in the traditional sense. No prescribed order of completion. No guidance beyond the initial tutorial. You emerged from the Shrine of Resurrection, took in the view of Hyrule spread out before you, and the game said: go.

What followed was one of the most celebrated open-world experiences in the history of the medium. The physics system was a toy of extraordinary richness. You could do almost anything the rules of the world should have allowed. Cut down a tree and ride the log into a river. Light a fire and ride the thermal it created to gain height. Use a metal object as a lightning rod in a thunderstorm. The game was built around the principle of systemic creativity, of giving the player tools and letting them find solutions that the designers had never imagined. The result was a game that generated stories. Every player had a Breath of the Wild story that was uniquely theirs.

The world of Hyrule was designed as a landscape to be read, with every elevation and every ruin placed to reward observation and curiosity. The 120 Shrines and 900 Korok Seeds provided structure without prescription. The story of what happened to Hyrule one hundred years before the game begins was told through memory fragments scattered across the map rather than through cutscenes, respecting the player's desire to discover rather than be told.

It is the overall 1 seed because it is, by the only objective measure we have, the best-reviewed game of the entire VGM era. That is what it brings to this matchup.

What Disco Elysium brings is something that cannot be summarized by a Metacritic score, even though its Metacritic score is also a 97.

Disco Elysium: The Final Cut scored a 97 on Metacritic with 54 reviews, the highest score of any game in the active field of this tournament. It is the 8 seed because review volume matters in the seeding formula, and 54 reviews is not 141. But the score is identical to the overall 1 seed, and the game is anything but lesser for having fewer critics write about it.

Disco Elysium was made by ZA/UM, an Estonian studio founded by novelist Robert Kurvitz, and it is an RPG in which there is no combat. None at all. The entire game is conversation, choice, and the consequences of choice, filtered through a skill system of 24 attributes that represent different facets of your character's psychology and physicality, each of which can interject during conversations and skill checks with their own observations and opinions. You play as a detective who wakes up in a hotel room with no memory of who he is or what he has done. You must investigate a murder, discover your own identity, and navigate the politics of a deeply strange postindustrial city called Revachol.

The game is funny, heartbreaking, politically complex, philosophically ambitious, and unlike anything else that has been made in the medium. The Final Cut, released in 2021, added full voice acting for the entire game, which represents an extraordinary amount of voice work given how much text Disco Elysium contains. It is the definitive version and the version that earned the 97.

Disco Elysium beat Resident Evil 2 in the Round of 64 by a score of 3-2, a result that confirmed its fanbase is organized and motivated and arrives at every matchup with something to prove on behalf of a game that the broader gaming world has never fully appreciated. Resident Evil 2 is a 91-rated remake of one of the most beloved survival horror games ever made. Disco Elysium beat it by one vote.

Now it faces the game with the highest score in VGM history, with its own score matching it exactly. A 97 against a 97. Systemic creativity against philosophical conversation. The game that generated stories through its world against the game that generated stories through its dialogue. The matchup the seedings make look like a foregone conclusion and the matchup the Round of 64 results suggest could be anything but.

The West bracket continues March 22. 12PM.

2026 Video Game Madness - West Region 2nd Round: 1 The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild vs. 8 Disco Elysium: The Final Cut

1 The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild

JPN

8 Disco Elysium: The Final Cut

EST

West Region Round of 32 Matchup Preview: 1 The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild vs. 8 Disco Elysium: The Final Cut

Previous Champions

social